Construction Dispute Resolution in Ireland: Adjudication, Arbitration, and Mediation
Written by Jack Doherty
Updated 23 October 2026
The Construction Contracts Act 2013 gives Irish contractors the right to adjudication for payment disputes - a fast, binding, and cost-effective route to recovering money owed. Understanding how adjudication, arbitration, and mediation work could recover significant sums for your business.
The Construction Contracts Act 2013
The Construction Contracts Act 2013 (CCA) is the primary statutory framework governing payment rights and dispute resolution in Irish construction contracts. The Act applies to most construction contracts. It does not cover contracts worth €10,000 or less, public private partnership contracts, or work on a home under 200 square metres where one of the parties lives or plans to live. The principal provisions include the right to interim payment, the prohibition on pay-when-paid clauses, the right to suspend work after following the required notice procedure, and the right to refer a payment dispute to adjudication. To dispute a claim, the paying party must give a written response to the payment claim notice no later than 21 days after the payment claim date, stating the amount it proposes to pay, its reasons and how it calculated it, and must still pay that proposed amount by the due date. The CCA fundamentally changed the power dynamic in Irish construction payment disputes - before the CCA, subcontractors often had no practical mechanism for recovering legitimate payments short of costly court proceedings.
Adjudication - the fast-track dispute resolution mechanism
Adjudication under the Construction Contracts Act 2013 is a 28-day dispute resolution process designed to provide rapid, cost-effective resolution of construction payment disputes. The process is: the party claiming payment serves a payment claim notice; the paying party must give a written response to the payment claim notice no later than 21 days after the payment claim date, stating the amount it proposes to pay, its reasons and how it calculated it, and must still pay that proposed amount by the due date; if the payment is disputed, either party can refer it to adjudication at any time by serving a notice of intention to refer on the other party; the parties then try to agree an adjudicator, and if they cannot, either party can apply to the Chairperson of the Construction Contracts Adjudication Panel, who appoints an adjudicator from the Minister's panel, usually within seven days; the adjudicator reaches a decision within 28 days of referral. The adjudicator's decision is binding until the dispute is finally settled by agreement, arbitration or the courts, so the paying party has to pay now and argue later. Adjudication has been used extensively by Irish construction companies since the CCA came into force and has proven to be a genuinely effective payment recovery mechanism.
Arbitration for complex and high-value disputes
Arbitration under the Arbitration Act 2010 is the appropriate dispute resolution mechanism for complex Irish construction disputes where the parties want a final and binding decision with greater procedural formality than adjudication. Arbitration is private and confidential (unlike court proceedings), the arbitrator is typically a specialist with construction industry expertise (a QS, engineer, or construction lawyer), and the process can be designed to suit the complexity of the specific dispute. RIAI, SCSI, and CIArb each operate arbitrator appointment panels for construction arbitrations. Arbitration awards are final and binding (with limited grounds for appeal) and are enforceable in Ireland and internationally under the New York Convention. The main disadvantages of arbitration compared to adjudication are cost and time - complex construction arbitrations can take months and cost EUR tens of thousands in fees. For most Irish construction SME payment disputes, adjudication provides a faster and cheaper resolution than arbitration.
Mediation for preserving relationships
Mediation is a voluntary, non-binding dispute resolution process where a neutral mediator assists the parties to reach a negotiated settlement. In construction disputes, mediation is most appropriate where: the commercial relationship between the parties is important and the parties want to preserve it (subcontractor-main contractor relationships, repeat client relationships); the dispute involves a mix of legitimate and unreasonable positions on both sides that a negotiated compromise could address; or the parties want to avoid the cost and time of adjudication or arbitration and are willing to negotiate. Mediation does not produce a binding outcome unless the parties reach a written settlement agreement - if mediation fails, the parties retain their rights to adjudication, arbitration, or litigation. Many Irish construction contracts now include a mediation step in the dispute resolution clause as a required pre-condition before adjudication or arbitration, particularly on larger projects. The Construction Law Reform Group (CLRG) and the Law Society of Ireland's Construction Law Committee provide guidance on mediation in Irish construction disputes.
Common questions about construction dispute resolution in Ireland
Can adjudication be used without a solicitor in Ireland?
Yes - adjudication under the Construction Contracts Act 2013 is specifically designed to be accessible without legal representation. The adjudication process is less formal than court proceedings, and many Irish construction companies conduct adjudications with commercial or QS representation rather than legal counsel. The key practical steps are: serving a valid payment claim notice under the Act (ensuring the notice correctly identifies the basis for the payment claim and the amount sought); checking the paying party's written response to the payment claim notice, which must arrive no later than 21 days after the payment claim date and state the amount it proposes to pay, its reasons and how it calculated it, with that proposed amount still payable by the due date; if the payment is disputed, serving a notice of intention to refer, agreeing an adjudicator with the other party or, failing agreement, applying to the Chairperson of the Construction Contracts Adjudication Panel for an appointment, and then submitting a referral setting out the claim, the evidence and the relief sought. For complex disputes involving large sums, legal or QS support is valuable - but for straightforward payment disputes where the facts are clear and the documentation is organised, adjudication without a solicitor is entirely viable and significantly reduces the cost of recovering legitimate payments.
What if the other party refuses to comply with an adjudicator's decision?
An adjudicator's decision under the Construction Contracts Act 2013 is binding unless and until it is revised by arbitration or litigation. If the losing party refuses to comply with the decision, the winning party can enforce the adjudicator's decision through the courts as a debt. Irish courts have consistently enforced adjudicator decisions in construction disputes, recognising the pay now, argue later principle that underpins the adjudication system. The usual route is an application to the High Court for leave to enforce the decision in the same way as a court judgment, under section 6(11) of the Act. The High Court first granted leave in Aakon Construction Services v Pure Fitout Associated (2021). Courts look at two things: whether the adjudicator had jurisdiction, and whether the process was fair. In 2025 the High Court refused enforcement in two cases, one where the adjudication notice was not delivered as the contract required and one where the dispute was not about a payment under the contract. Get the notices right and keep the dispute to payment. The combination of binding decision and court enforcement makes adjudication a genuinely effective payment recovery mechanism for Irish construction companies.
Is adjudication better than court action for Irish construction disputes?
For most construction payment disputes, adjudication is significantly better than court action. The key advantages of adjudication over court proceedings are: speed (adjudication decisions are typically reached within 28 days of referral, compared to months or years for court proceedings); cost (adjudication is substantially cheaper than High Court litigation); and the pay now, argue later principle (the losing party must pay the adjudicator's decision promptly, with the option to challenge through arbitration or litigation if they believe the decision is wrong - this shifts the cash flow burden onto the party withholding payment rather than the party waiting for payment). The main limitation of adjudication is that decisions can be challenged in arbitration or litigation, meaning adjudication provides immediate payment rather than final resolution. For disputes involving complex factual or legal issues where the final outcome matters as much as the immediate cash flow, arbitration or litigation may be appropriate. However, for the most common Irish construction dispute scenario - a subcontractor or main contractor waiting for legitimate payment from a principal contractor - adjudication is the fastest, cheapest, and most effective remedy.
Jack Doherty
Founder and CVO, WDI
Jack founded WDI, which builds and runs email and LinkedIn outreach for Irish B2B and construction companies.
LinkedIn_1767552465140-DF70JoAZ.jpeg)